• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Indianhead Supper Club

Indianhead Supper Club, nestled in Balsam Lake, Wisconsin, offers a unique dining experience reminiscent of classic supper clubs. The establishment features a warm, inviting ambiance adorned with interesting Native American artwork, making it a cozy spot for adults seeking fine dining. Customers rave about the exquisite cuisine, highlighting dishes like BBQ ribs served on a cedar plank and seafood jambalaya. Exceptional service enhances the experience, with staff known for their friendliness and efficiency. While prices are slightly elevated due to the high quality of offerings, every meal promises a memorable occasion, perfect for celebrating special events in a quaint lakeside setting.

Indianhead Supper Club: Reviews & Ratings

Blaise Vitale
Blaise Vitale

My wife and I ate here as part of a group. We'd never been here before. I am glad that they've kept the moderately politically incorrect name. The place is well-maintained with some interesting dated native American artwork. The food was quite good. I had the Seafood Jambalaya and my wife had the maple glazed walleye, and both were excellent. The service was pleasant and efficient, particularly being part of a group of 14. Ambience was casual but friendly. Prices are moderately high but not extravagant. We are likely to eat here again.

Outdoor Girl
Outdoor Girl

I have eaten at Indianhead Supper Club 3 times and everytime, my supper was 5 star quality. You wouldn't expect the old fashioned fine dining in this rural area, but it's exqusite with that old fashioned dining experience. I've had both the 1/2 Chicken and BBQ Ribs and it was some of the best cuisine I have eaten on this side of the border. Beautiful quaint atmosphere with fine dining experience and a lake view. Did I say the BBQ Ribs were A-MAZ-ING? Indeed they were. Best ribs I've ever had and they come on a cedar plank and they are melt in your mouth with actual meat on them! Highly recommend this restaurant for your extra special celebrations. Meals are priced higher than other restaurants in the area because the food is high quality. This is not a place where you bring your kids. This is an adult dining experience. I have never been there when there was live music so I don't know where they would do that. There's no dancefloor. Maybe it's something they do outside in the summer??? You'd have to call them and ask about that. Bathrooms are downstairs for those with disabilities. We have always arrived around 5:00pm and sometimes have been some of the first people there because once 5:30 rolls around, it starts getting busy fast! Last time, they were short staffed until more waiters come on duty, but you're there to DINE. If you want it faster, go to a fast food restaurant. This is where you come to dine. Celebrate your special day with delicious cuisine and a cozy atmosphere.

Abbey Tebben
Abbey Tebben

The staff was exceptional. Great food (warm Brie, prime rib, sirlion, creme brulee and lava cake)! Very accommodating when we called last minute and they were full but squeezed us in! Heather was a great server and the staff was all so friendly! Sorry no more food photos as we ate everything too quick!

Gary A
Gary A

We had a dinner party of seven. Service was very good and prompt. I would suggest the restaurant add at least one or two vegetarian and vegan options. Not for me! Prime ribs was to live FOR! Not die for, that’s dumb.

Tim Weinberg
Tim Weinberg

Wonderful place, a step back in time to the old time supper clubs. We went to the supper club because of "Old Fashioned" the supper club book. Our meals were great and we will be back a again. You will not be disappointed. Thanks for everything

Jeremy Anderson
Jeremy Anderson

The food was amazing. The staff was amazing. My wife and I had a great date dinner and drinks. Well worth every penny spent.

Shari Christianson
Shari Christianson

This place embodies everything a supper club should be. From the gracious and wonderful hostess, Jan, to our friendly and efficient waitress, Jenna, and the most succulent and tender prime rib I've ever tasted, you can't get any better than this place. I hope to be back many times.

Blake Yunker
Blake Yunker

Wife and I stopped for date night and sat at the bar with Mark. Best food, drinks and service as always! Had the crab stuffed salmon tonight and the wife had Chicken Picatta with shrimp on the side. We will be back soon!

Location

Welcome to the Indianhead Supper Club, a hidden gem nestled in the serene surroundings of Balsam Lake, Wisconsin. Here, you’re not just dining; you're experiencing a slice of nostalgic Americana. The supper club, located at 107 Indianhead Shores Drive, invites you to step back in time, where the tradition of elegant dining blends seamlessly with a casual, friendly atmosphere.

As you enter, you are greeted by a charming decor that nods to its roots, featuring interesting native American artwork that tells a story of culture and heritage. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the perfect setting for intimate dinners or festive gatherings. Whether you’re part of a large group or on a romantic escape, the Indianhead Supper Club promises to deliver an unforgettable experience.

Now, let’s talk about the food. Patrons rave about the quality of dishes like the Seafood Jambalaya and the Maple Glazed Walleye, both prepared to perfection and bursting with flavor. One reviewer, Blaise Vitale, shared his delight in these offerings, highlighting their excellence in taste and presentation. And if you’re in the mood for something different, the BBQ Ribs—served on a cedar plank—are renowned for being mouth-watering and tender, making them a must-try for rib lovers.

Vegetarians may find their options limited, but the robust selection of meats, including the Prime Rib praised by many, ensures that carnivores will leave satisfied. The culinary team takes pride in sourcing high-quality ingredients, which is reflected in every bite.

Service at the Indianhead Supper Club has garnered much appreciation. With staff members described as friendly and efficient, you can count on a pleasant dining experience, whether you’re part of a party of fourteen or a couple enjoying a quiet evening. Despite occasional staffing delays, as mentioned by loyal customers, the emphasis here is on quality and a leisurely dining experience rather than rushed meals.

If you’re looking to celebrate a special occasion or simply indulge in a night of fine dining, Indianhead Supper Club is your destination. Just remember, the prices reflect the quality of the cuisine, and it’s an adult-only venue—perfect for those seeking an upscale night out. Add this culinary haven to your Wisconsin dining itinerary, and prepare to fall in love with each exceptional dish!